Disruptor at the Met for Iolanta/Bluebeard Premire

Last night the delayed NP of Iolanta/Bluebeard was interrupted by this man. I reviewed the entire performance for Parterre Box.

The Met’s planned premiere of Iolanta/Bluebeard’s Castle was cancelled due to the Great Blizzard That Wasn’t. All ticket holders were given refunds and exchanges, and the premiere was moved to January 29. As a result the lobby of the Met pre-performance was a noisy zoo. The will call line spiraled almost to the basement stairs and my! all that fur (on both the men and the women). Outside was a small but noisy group of protestors. It’s understandable that the Met staff seemed a bit frazzled and overwhelmed. They came, they sang, they bowed. Anna Netrebko and Piotr Beczala are audience favorites, and so of course there were bravos and bouquets. Then, at the end of the performance a man just strolled onstage using the stage right stairs, and unveiled a poster of of the Ukraine flag with pictures of Valery Gergiev, Netrebko… and Hitler. The cast was clearly frazzled (although they were singing behind a production scrim) and the crowd began to boo the intrepid protestor. Almost as if on cue professional photographers ran down the aisle snapping pictures. And just as calmly, the man walked offstage. The protestor I think earned the
 Iolanta cast some sympathy points. That was handy, because the performance was sort of disappointing. Tchaikovsky’s last opera has been a favorite vehicle for Netrebko in concert, and she’s sung this role onstage in the exact same production. I won’t point out the link but a whole performance is easily searchable on youtube. Maybe it’s sentimentality that’s kept this role in Netrebko’s repertoire because at the point in her career neither her voice nor her stage appearance really suit the role of the sheltered, blind princess. Netrebko’s now rather mature looking and what’s more, acts mature. The youthful ebullience is no longer really there. When she rolled around on the floor and twirled it almost seemed like a nostalgic throwback to her earlier days. It didn’t look natural.
Her voice has also changed. She always had a dark, rich timbre, but in this rather lyrical role one noticed a thickness to her voice that sounded matronly. It had a slight but persistent beat on sustained notes. Her pitch sagged. What was most surprising was how often she seemed to be pushing. In the past, Netrebko didn’t have to strain to be loud. She just had reserves of volume. It was like she opened her mouth, and the sound filled the auditorium. Tonight in the duet with Vaudémont (Beczala) and in the final wedding chorus she was hunched over, fists balled, screaming. I really want to think this was just a bad night for Anna, because I’ve heard her in almost everything she’s ever sung at the Met and she’s never sounded this bad. And she was spectacular as Lady Macbeth this past fall.
Beczala is actually five years older than Netrebko but is still believable in these lyric prince roles. His voice is for the most part an incredibly well preserved light tenor. On the highest notes one can detect a thinning of the sound and some strain, but the core of his voice has stayed the same. More amazing is that he can still pull off the ardent lover schtick. If Netrebko’s voice is a bit like an aged fine wine, Beczala is more like amber. You can pull out videos from more than 10 years ago, and compare them with today. He hasn’t changed. And when you saw him smirking a little after the ovation for his aria it was so cute. Never change!
The low voices were distressing. Whatever happened to Russia’s lower-voiced males? They used to be the greatest bass factory in the world. Ilya Bannik (King René) was the understudy for an ailing Alexei Tanovitsky so one couldn’t expect too much, but he doesn’t have even a cover voice. He has a thin, wobbly comprimario voice.  Elchin Azizov (Ibn-Hakia) was almost as bad. Alexei Markov (Duke Robert) at least had a voice, although it wasn’t beautiful.
Gergiev has remarkably little feel for Tchaikovsky’s music. This is as much of a problem in the Nutcracker recording of his as Iolanta. He has a cold clinical style, which is absolutely against the grain of Tchaikovsky’s melodies. The final wedding chorus fizzled out to the point where when the curtain fell there was little to no applause.
Mariusz Trelinski’s production of Iolanta was the lesser of his two efforts. It’s set in a chilly hunting lodge, with some deer hanging on the walls and a dead deer that drips blood. I liked the austere look for most of the opera. It suggested a bone-chilling Russian winter. The stage blocking was formulaic and the “transformation” however pretty lame. Everyone just put on some wedding gear and held hands and belted.
After the intermission we got the grim aftermath to the fairy tale ending of Iolanta. Bartok’s Bluebeard’s Castle is not as easy and accessible a work as Iolanta. It has only two voices, and the story is dark and creepy. With that being said, I loved it. First, Trelinski apparently saved all his good ideas for Bluebeard. The production was surreal, imaginative, and almost cinematic. I won’t spoil many of the production’s effects (the way he handles the Seventh Key is a doozy) but let’s just say it’s a scene Ted Bundy might have approved of, in his sick sociopath way.
And what of the two protagonists? Well for Mikhail Petrenko (Bluebeard) I’ll repeat: what happened to Russia’s basses? This voiceless, wobbly dude is the best they can get? Judith was “soprano” Nadja Michael. Previously I had only heard on recording and in soprano parts like Lady Macbeth and Salome. The screechy white tone was cringe inducing. Well tonight I think I finally figured Michael out. I think she’s really a contralto. In the lower register (where much of the role lies) her voice has a richness and resonance that is (dare I say it) quite intriguing. It’s not beautiful, but it’s not the trademark caterwauling that one hears on the DVD’s. Only when she has to sing in the soprano tessitura does the white, shrill tone emerge.
Petrenko and Michael don’t have A-list voices but they did throw themselves into the production completely. This opera has a rather abstract libretto but Petrenko and Michael made the characters flesh and blood people. He bond between husband and wife was well developed. There was tenderness, sexual attraction, fear, and finally, a chilling acceptance. Bartok’s score is “difficult” but deeply rewarding. I loved how the music became less dissonant with each door. The seventh door music was almost like Tchaikovsky. Death never seemed so seductive. It was a wonderful musical experience, and what I’ll most remember from the night.
Trelinski said Alfred Hitchcock films inspired him when he planned these productions. With this insight in mind I’ll just say that Hitch would have called the Iolanta half (replete with the noisy protestor) the MacGuffin. The lush music, fairy tale marriage story, and curtain call antics were just a trick for the audiences to appreciate the bone-chilling story of Bluebeard and his doomed wives.


  1. I really hope it was just a bad night for Netrebko, she did not sound like her best. Hope those Lady Macbeth's didn't affect her voice. I'm so excited to see the Bluebeard though, it's one of my favorite operas but I've been very reluctant about Nadja Michael. She was a lovely Brangäne way back in 2000 (at Carnegie Hall, with the unforgettable Waltraud Meier) but her Salome was less than mediocre and her Lady Macbeth was a total disaster. However, based on your review and the tidbits I've been hearing on youtube she sounds surprisingly ok in the part and she nails the high c in the rehearsal clip. So I'm very excited.

    1. I don't think it's the Lady Macbeths. I just think that her voice doesn't sound very fresh or young anymore, and there's really nothing she can do about it as few 40-something year old sopranos sound young and fresh. Iolanta however is a role where sounding young and fresh is sort of a prerequisite. I think Netrebko might be more suited to more grown up roles at this time.

    2. That's what I'm thinking/hoping. I would very much like her to sing in Il Trovatore some time soon.

    3. She did sing Il Trovatore! There's even a DVD of her performance:


  2. oh, I meant at the met. I've seen both videos and think that, at least from a vocal point of view, they are the best things I've ever heard from her.


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

COVIDammerung -- The End of the World in Met Streams

Comparing Nutcrackers Across the Pond

Angela Meade's Anna